You CAN'T be BOTH Christian and Muslim. Stupid.

Discussion on myLot : http://www.mylot.com/w/discussions/1884326.aspx#2_18846388

As posted by a myLot member:

A friend asked me what religion I was and I said I was a Islamic Christian, and he asked what was that.
And I told him a person who believes in the teaching of bothe religions.
There are somethings in both religionsI totally know are true and agree with.
But in both religions there are somethings I do not agree with.
Actually I may become some other religions also.
What rule says I can not be more than one religion?

Why do I have to just stay with one? Is it wrong for me to respect & learn about others religious beliefs?
I am a person who believes that you can not love GOD is you do not love his peoples
and their beliefs and religions.

He created us all. We are not GOD and in all religious books it says to honor
The CREATOR and respect The CREATOR.

So why do people hate other peoples religion?
Did not your CREATOR tell you to love all and respect them?

So what is wrong with me being ore than one religion?
all I am doing is loving and respecting like My GOD has asked me to.

My Response:
You're part of a certain religion if you were baptized in it. So you really can't be Islamic Christian because both faiths doesn't allow you to be baptized in any other religion except for one - if you were baptized Islam then baptized Christian after that then you're Christian because that's the last profession of faith that you had.

The CREATOR told us to become stewardess of His Creation. The CREATOR in Christianity refers to the God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit as three persons in ONE Triune God. In contrast to that, the Muslims believe that Christ is human and not God - they are "anti-Christs" in the most authentic sense of the term. They're Allah is one person in one God. The difference in faith is much too grave to consolidate in one person - this is impossible and I am afraid that you should rethink your notion of being Islamic Christian because there is no such thing.

Comment of another member on my response:

So you really can't be Islamic Christian because both faiths doesn't allow you to be baptized in any other religion except for one

Sorry but thats not true...i have a couple of friends who are Christian Pagans (one is a Catholic Pagan) and their belief is that its between them and their God...which is how it should be...Just because YOU dont agree its possible doesnt mean its not possible..The OP obviously is comfortable following a mixture of religions and I say BRAVO to that..

I am afraid that you should rethink your notion of being Islamic Christian because there is no such thing.

According to YOU...but obviously there is since the OP is Islamic Christian..

Comment of discussion-starter:

How can there be no such thing?
Ghandi was 2 religions. And Ghandi was a very great prophet.
Actually I was never baptised to no religion I do have my certificate stating that I am
a muslim. I read the bible and the quran.

Not every christian believes the same. ALLAH is not a person, not a human.
There is only one GOD. He is called by many names.
But those names are all the same name.
The name sounds different to us because it is pronounced differently by different tongues.

And acutually I can call my self a Islamic Christian.
Why because there are people whoase religion is universalism.
The believe in all religions.

See when you only believe in one religion you close your mind to GOD.
Whe you start pointing out things in other religions you start to judge.
and in all religions GOD says not to judge.
So when people judge are they really being true to GOD.
And the one GOD we have made all people.
GOD did not make religion. Man made religion.
man seperated themselves into little groups called religion.
In reality we are all the same.
We all need water and food to survive.

I appreciate your opinion, but I will still be an Islamic Christian until I die.
i love both religions and it's people.
And I am sorry but I refuse to choose one.
Because they are both beautiful religions with beautiful peoples.

Comment of another member:
What do you mean by prophet ghandi

Response to the comment by the discussion-starter:

I meant just what I said Ghandi was a prophet. Just because you may not believe he was a prophet I do.
I believe he was here to give a message and he did .
People chose not to listen. Ghandi was a very peaceful person.
He was a great person.

My response:
Gandhi never prophesied anything so that means he's not a prophet.

Even though you have certificates that say your are both Muslim and Christian or Pagan and Catholic - it doesn't mean you are. You can believe in whatever you want to be but you can't call yourself as member of two opposing institutions - belief and institutional faith are not the same thing.

What you have is mixed belief - you're what we call a buffet believer. You go to a buffet of faiths then pick what you agree on and disregard what you don't believe in.

If you don't believe that Christ is God then you're not a Christian. That includes believing that Christ was both man and God.

If however you do believe this then you can't be Muslim because their doctrines say otherwise.

I do not mean to offend, only to clarify. You can also test your beliefs against your Christian friends and against your Muslim friends - tell them of your "compromised faith" and ask them what they think about it. You will get the same answers.

Unfortunately, I'm only telling you facts and not opinions so however you feel about my answer, I can't take them back because they're the truth.


Comment of discussion-starter to my response:

Well all that you say is not fact. There are some christians who do not believe
GOD was a man. And as far as all religions are concerned there is truth in
them and then there is some stuff man has thrown in there to satisfy him self.

You, nor I or anyother human being knows it all. only the being that created us does.
We are not perfect and make many mistakes and make laspe in judgement all the time.
Non of us is always right and that is why fact sometimes is hard to prove.

Allah is not a person. and for you tosoeak about a religion that you have never practiced or study is wrong.
that is like saying people of a certain color are all canibals.

It is ridiculous.
And the Christian bible says not to judge!
but as I read your statements you are upset and judging.
I thought not following the word of GOD in the christian religion was disobediant.
If I am wrong correct me.

But I am sure the bible says not to judge and I am sure it also speaks about not
following the word of GOD is being disrespectful and disobediant.
I kinds read the bible everyday.I also kinda read the quran everyday.

Infact I have both sitting here as I type.
and before I start talking about religions I always make sure I know a little
bit of the truth by studying them before I start trying to offend people.
and when I do study I find that I can not offend because what I
was taught usually was something hateful.
The hate between religions really needs to end.
It is children and selfish.
Because it obviously is only one way we got here.
and we all are still trying to figure it out.
If we were not we not have scientist and archeologist digging and studying the past right now.

My response:
Christianity is called as it is exactly because we believe that "Christ is God". And that Christ is both MAN and God.

You can believe all you want with whatever you say, and I am not judging you as a person. I am stating facts about faiths that even priest and imams would clarify for you.

Comment by the same member who commented first on my response:

I am stating facts about faiths that even priest and imams would clarify for you

Sorry hun but they ARE NOT "facts" they are opinions..and I know a few ministers etc who would DISAGREE with you to the fullest..

My response:
Fact: Christians believe that Christ is God. Source: http://geneva.rutgers.edu...

Fact: Muslims believe that Christ is NOT God but is a prophet. Source: http://wiki.answers.com/Q...

Logical Fact: Christians believe that Christ is God. Muslim don't believe that Christ is God. You cannot believe that Christ is God and not God at the same time.